One of the most famous space missions in history…was a failure.
Apollo 13 ended up not being the third manned space mission to land on the moon, not after an explosion of the service module’s oxygen tank crippled the mission just two days after launch and endangered the lives of all three crew members.
Memorialized in the aptly named movie Apollo 13, starring Tom Hanks, the trio of astronauts used the moon lander as a “lifeboat.” Mission Control in Houston improvised new procedures to allow a ship designed for two men to stay on the moon for two days to instead keep three men alive for four days as they looped around the moon and successfully returned home.
It’s a fantastic movie, and one of my favorites. I grew up in Florida and was always fascinated by space, and I could go on for thousands of words about both the movie and the mission itself. The situation itself was fascinating, and the movie has gorgeous cinematography.
One of the less cinematic parts of the trip home was an electrical budget.
The lunar module’s batteries needed to run twice as long as intended, all while supporting another person, since the command module’s self-contained power system needed to be conserved for reentry. Mission Control and the crew needed to debate and decide every milliamp - what could run, what couldn’t, and what had to be saved for later.
For the Braves, their electrical budget is instead going to be measured in rotation innings.
Alex Anthopoulos appeared on national MLB reporter Jon Heyman’s podcast on Tuesday, discussing Spencer Schwellenbach’s more optimistic outlook on his return. The right-hander is starting a throwing program next week and is expected to be available in spring training.
But the Braves still need to plan for everything that comes after that first start he makes in 2027: the days he gets extra rest, the outings they choose to end early, and the innings that someone else has to pick up in his place.
How do the Braves manage a rotation that has several members who might all need extra rest, and how does this news change Atlanta’s offseason?
Let’s talk about it.
We all had the timeline wrong
No one’s really sure where it came from, but there was this idea that Spencer Schwellenbach wouldn’t be available early next year as he works his way back from a surgical repair of his 2025 broken elbow.
Alex was clear that we were all wrong. “I know there was some reports that Schwellenbach wouldn’t be ready for spring. That’s not accurate. It’s just a matter of, ‘Is that the right thing for us to do?’”
Alex said that Schwellenbach, who he spoke to last week, was preparing to start his offseason throwing program around Thanksgiving, and Alex preached caution and patience. “You don’t need to rush to be back,” he told Schwellenbach, adding that the “expectation” is that he would be ready to go by spring but it was ultimately up to doctors, physical therapists, and the training staff to decide how aggressively to push this winter.
(A complicating factor is that players rehabbing from injury are not allowed to be in contact with team doctors or trainers, although it’s possible that his third-party doctor could serve as a go-between, updating the team on his rehab throughout the winter.)
Alex was careful to mention that they’re not guaranteeing him a spot in the rotation on Opening Day, leaving open the possibility that he might not break camp with the team. “We’re probably going to want to take our time and be careful.”
Alex was also explicit that the team can’t build the plan around having both of them in 2027, reportedly telling that to both players. “I’ve told them this: it’s hard for us to go into the season and we count on them. If they’re back and they’re healthy and they’re ready to go, we’ll easily make room. That’s a great problem to have, right? So, we’ll definitely have spots, but I don’t think that we can plan. And I don’t think it’s prudent for us to sit there and say, ‘Okay, we’re going to give these guys, we expect to get 30 starts in 180 innings or close to that out of these guys.’”
So, if they’re not expected to give a full workload, what is a reasonable expectation and how do the Braves cover those innings? A six-man rotation is a possible solution, but it comes with a cost Anthopoulos has already explained.
The repair he had and the workload after
Schwellenbach’s original injury in 2025 was a fracture of the olecranon, the bony protuberance at the end of your elbow. He deliberately tried to avoid surgery by rehabbing it, but after being unable to bounce back from a subsequent elbow scope for loose bodies and a bone spur, he finally had the surgery late last season.
There are several surgical approaches to an olecranon fracture, but Schwellenbach underwent an ORIF - open reduction and internal fixation. In essence, the broken bone is put back into place and secured with hardware.
What we don’t know is the exact type of hardware used on Schwellenbach: One screw, inserted through the broken end of his elbow and extending down into the ulna? Multiple screws to secure a plate? A long plate, which requires making a small space in the triceps for the head of the plate to come around to the humerus?
But what we do know is this type of surgery, contrary to what most think, is NOT a death knell for an MLB pitcher. Braves Today obtained a copy of a 2019 study done in conjunction with Major League Baseball and with access to the league’s internal Health and Injury Tracking System, which broke down 52 professional players who underwent olecranon fracture fixation from 2010 through 2016.
The return-to-play rate was about 67.5% in the study, while 57.6% got back to the same professional level.
Those numbers sound scary, but they encompass everyone from established major leaguers to fringe minor leaguers and organizational players, some of which were on their way out of the game at the time of the injury.
What’s more helpful is knowing that the returners did not show any significant decline in the measured performance metrics.
Joel Zumaya’s the scary one here - he had the screw placed in 2010 and never returned to the majors. That’s the comp that everyone’s throwing out…but he had an extensive injury history before this, including a ruptured tendon in his hand, an offseason separated shoulder that bothered him for an entire season, eventually requiring surgery, and even needed a revision of his olecranon repair. Also, part of the reason he didn’t return was suffering a torn UCL in 2012 and struggling with the rehab.
Al Alburquerque returned from having his screw inserted to pick up right where he left off with the Tigers, while Braves starter Gavin Floyd returned to the league as a reliever after his surgery. Jason Adam’s another starter-turned-reliever, but he also lost two seasons after an infection and a revision ended up totaling three surgeries on the same elbow.
So, an encouraging medical outcome would still leave Atlanta with a baseball problem: how much should Atlanta ask Schwellenbach to do, and who handles the rest?
What does a six-man rotation actually cut out?
Think about how many of Atlanta’s rotation options have prescriptions for extra rest next year: The Braves have already decided that’s when Chris Sale is at his best, while Didier Fuentes will likely need extra rest to mitigate his workload increase and both Schwellenbach and Spencer Strider are coming off of injuries and small (or nonexistent) 2026 workloads.
A full 162-game season and an evenly shared schedule means the five starters would make 32 or 33 starts each; six starters would be at 27 each. A perfectly reasonable 5½ innings per start on 27 starts would produce a workload of close to 150 innings each.
And obviously, this is before any sort of schedule tricks allow the Braves to buy more rest: skipping turns thanks to spot starters, or pushing everyone back thanks to a well-timed off day.
The problem is that Anthopoulos has discussed how hard it is to run a six-man rotation for any significant length of time, as he explained to Braves Today last November:
“You’re gonna have to go (with a) seven-man bullpen, and if you can pull it off where you’re gonna get six starters that give you at least five (innings), you know, six (innings) and so on. The problem with it is you get a two-inning start, a one-inning start, two and a third, and you’re playing 18 (games) in a row, 20 in a row, whatever it is. You’re cooked at that point, right?”
Let’s talk about what this could look like in practice, as an example.
Schwellenbach’s the starter on a Tuesday night in the series opener and takes a comebacker to that surgically repaired elbow in the third inning, so they pull him from the game out of an “abundance of caution”. The next night, we get the bad Bryce Elder and he gets lit up for six runs in four innings, and the Braves need to cover five innings after covering five and a third the previous night. A seven-man bullpen just pitched the equivalent of an entire game in two days, and there’s no off day until the following Monday.
Now, Atlanta’s preference for multi-inning relievers helps, but those guys are typically down for at least one day (and often two) after pitching multiple innings.
A workable six-man rotation requires length from other starters, as well as quality multi-inning coverage. And as we saw at times this last season, you need enough quality depth to make a push in a game you have a chance of winning. And with the current roster rules, you can’t make unlimited, immediate swaps with the minors, either.
Atlanta may be forced to go with more of the “aggressively buying rest” route rather than a strict six-man rotation, which worked out well for the Braves that season. “ I do think there’s real value to it, and you guys saw it in 2024 when we led all of MLB and ERA. We used the off days, we moved guys back. We really protected guys and it worked well for us.”
But even then, Alex said it was a strain both on their depth and the front office. “ It was challenging because we were shuttling guys in and out and putting spot starters in. And from a ‘roster gymnastics’ standpoint, that’s what we call it, it was tough. You could only option guys five times a year. Once you option them, they’re down for two weeks. You’d have to have enough depth to not only call someone else, but it be a player of enough quality to not feel like you’re throwing the game away.”
Obviously, a new CBA could allow either a 27th roster spot that’s designated for a starting pitcher, essentially codifying six-man rotations, or a removal of the strict 13/13 limit that dictates how many pitchers and position players you can carry at any given time.
Because without loosening the current roster rules, a true six-man rotation might not be doable. “I’d love to be able to do it, (but) I just don’t know how realistic it is to be able to do it over the course of a season. […] The alternative is to try to put in spot starters and that’s been our best attempt to do it and still be able to maintain a roster.”
Where do the Braves go from here?
Schwellenbach’s return would be a welcome sight, both for a fanbase that has sorely missed having multiple top-of-the-rotation starters and a player who undoubtedly had some doubt creep in about if he’d ever be able to resume his career.
But Anthopoulos said it himself: They can’t build the rotation around even having Schwellenbach or Strider, never mind them carrying a respectable share of the workload. Sure, if your expectations for Schwellenbach were practically zero in 2027 (and Steamer was close, projecting roughly 30 innings for him in 2027), then this raises the ceiling of the rotation.
But the Braves still need one starter who does not require a load management plan. If they trust Tyler Mahle to give 150 innings for a second consecutive season, then he can be that guy. If they think old man Sonny Gray’s still got it, make the deal and #BringHimHome.
But you can’t build the entire rotation out of guys that are being handled with kid gloves.
And unless the sixth starter is codified in the new CBA, Atlanta likely can’t pick a full-time guy. Use it like a tool, either running six when the schedule permits or through targeted use of spot starters, exploiting off days, and pushing guys back. It worked in 2024, so take that institutional knowledge and apply it again.
But also realize that optionable, legitimate starting depth matters a ton. This doesn’t need to be “someone who can technically start”, but rather getting guys like J.R. Ritchie, Owen Murphy, AJ Smith-Shawver, and even some of the yet-to-debut prospects to the point where you’re comfortable asking for five innings without, in Alex’s words, throwing the game away.
Atlanta needs to decide how it will power the entire trip.
Apollo 13 didn’t make it home because they found another batter tucked away behind a maintenance hatch. Mission Control figured out how much power they actually had, decided what absolutely needed it, and stopped spending electricity on virtually everything else.
Tuesday’s Schwellenbach news gives the Braves a little more power than we thought we had a week ago. That’s unquestionably good news.
But don’t spend the innings just yet.
If he gives you 150 innings, fantastic. If Strider does, even better. But the offseason plan still needs to work if neither one does, because the quickest way to run out of power is to budget for electricity you don’t actually have.
That’s the calculation Anthopoulos needs to make before this thing ever gets off the ground.



Nice analogy linking Apollo 13's challenges to managing a pitching staff..
Nothing but silence on Mahle. I sure don't want to wake up tomorrow and see that he has signed with, maybe, the Mets or Phillies? At least Gray had the courtesy to sigh with an AL team.
Another mail bag question:
Why do you think we did not get Sonny Gray? Did the Braves not get Gray because it was: 1. Too much money? 2. Too many years? 3. AA doesn't give opt outs?
I guess my question is: Is this "proof" that AA's way doesn't/can't/won't get results in the FA market?