A project car still has value even if it’s not ready to start a cross-country trip tomorrow.
That’s essentially the calculation the Braves are making today, with the Rule 5 protection deadline coming at 6 PM ET.
Atlanta has a long list of Rule 5-eligible players, but that doesn’t mean they need to protect everyone they like. Yes, another organization can select an exposed minor leaguer for $100,000. But that team has to find a way to keep that player on their 26-man MLB roster all season, or else they’re required to offer him back to you for only $50,000; plenty of Rule 5 picks end up being returned near the end of spring training.
So this isn’t exactly a “protect anyone that’s remotely talented” deadline.
Instead, it’s a “protect the project cars that are complete enough to leave the garage and stay on the road all year” deadline.
And that distinction matters for Atlanta, because some of its most interesting eligible players still need development time in the minors, but some of the underrated names have exactly the sort of profile that a team could successfully float on its MLB roster all season.
There’s also the complicating factor of the Collective Bargaining Agreement expiring on Dec 1st, eight days before the Rule 5 Draft is tentatively scheduled to take place.
So, who does Atlanta actually need to protect?
Let’s talk about it.
The obvious protect
Let’s talk about Davis Polo.
Because while he’s not exactly ready for the majors, his trajectory in 2026 could convince someone to try.
Polo returned from missing all of 2025 to rocket through the entire farm system - starting in Single-A Augusta, he wrapped his season with a six-inning scoreless start for Triple-A Gwinnett.
All told, it was a 3.00 ERA with 140 strikeouts in 129 innings, logging a 1.08 WHIP. Oh, and he did it at age 21, having just turned 22 a few weeks ago. As we talked about a few weeks ago, you don’t speedrun the entire farm system in a single season on accident.
He’s talented, and it’s likely that a rebuilding team could look at a 22-year-old with four pitches that he can throw for strikes, coming off a breakout season, and think “we can carry him as our long man and eighth reliever for a year.”
While he has things to work on - I’m not a fan of the four-seam fastball shape, which flashed a 73 Stuff+ score in his AAA start, while the entire arsenal grades out just below average via Stuff+ - he has the potential to be an impact starter one day, and the major league bullpen experience would be valuable.
My verdict: Protect him.
Even if Atlanta thinks he needs another year in the minors to improve the stuff and find a tick or two of more velo, I don’t want to gamble on him making those improvements for someone else.
The other easy call
And it’s a pretty conventional argument, not needing to bank on hypothetical improvements: Cedric De Grandpre.
Starting in High-A Rome and making it to Gwinnett by the end of the year, he put up a 4.23 ERA this season across his 129.2 innings. He struck out 162 to 60 walks, a 29% strikeout rate. His whiffs were fueled by his stuff, significantly improved since 2024’s Tommy John surgery, but with some control questions.
And unlike Polo, De Grandpre’s stuff could likely play in a major league bullpen right now. He throws both four- and two-seam fastballs that sit in the mid-90s and can touch 98, while he can draw whiffs in a few different ways. His gyro slider’s a hard and tight breaker in the upper-80s, while his curveball’s pretty sweeper-ish and he throws a kick change that has a ton of potential.
This is a pretty well-worn path for some teams in the Rule 5 draft - take a starting pitching prospect, throw him in the pen for a year to both teach him how to get big leaguers out and have a role for him, and then move him back to the rotation with better stuff and some big league experience to see what happens.
My verdict: Protect him.
The stuff could play in a big league bullpen right now, and the Braves were willing to use their prospects in relief last season, so he might as well get those innings for Atlanta this season rather than someone else.
The sneaky one
Not a lot of people are talking about Luis Vargas, but they should be. He moved to the bullpen for good after the 2024 season, and has given the organization 89.1 innings of 3.43 ERA baseball with 134 strikeouts to 54 walks.
He’s not the type of pitcher that Atlanta’s gone to in the bullpen under Jeremy Hefner, throwing just a high-90s four-seamer and a filthy slider. He can’t always control either one, but he’s got the raw stuff to become a power arm out of the pen for Atlanta once he has a better idea of where they’re going and can supplement what he’s doing with one more pitch.
But just because the Braves aren’t ready to use him doesn’t mean someone else isn’t. He had 49 relief appearances last year and threw 67.2 innings, doing everything from single or multi-inning save situations to three-inning bulk outings after a starter left early.
He already misses bats, he’s already comfortable in relief, and he’s already faced high-minors hitters. If that’s not Rule 5-shaped, what is?
This is another example, just like our Rookie of the Year discussion last week, that sometimes it’s not about who is the best prospect, but who has the combination of skill set and circumstances to take advantage of an opportunity.
My verdict: I’d strongly consider protecting Vargas.
The uncomfortable decision
There are families that have proven to be absolute dynasties across sports: The Matthews family in football, the Williams family in tennis, or the Hull family in hockey.
And then sometimes, there’s a family where they’re all full of potential but can’t quite seem to reach the mountaintop. Drue Hackenberg’s part of one of those other families.
One brother, Adam, was a catcher in the White Sox and Blue Jays systems for five years before being released for the final time in July 2026. His oldest brother, Christian, was a second-round pick of the NFL’s New York Jets in 2016 and bounced through four organizations, never suiting up for a game, before retiring after the 2018 season. Yet another brother, Brandon, was a first-round pick in the 2021 MLS SuperDraft before retiring in January of 2023.
Drue’s the last man standing, and he’s on thin ice. He rebounded from a disastrous injury-influenced stretch with Columbus in 2025 (6.99 ERA) to make the AA-to-AAA transition this year and put up a 4.84 ERA across 21 appearances (17 starts). But a strikeout rate of just 23.7% isn’t that impressive when paired with a 10.7% walk rate and a groundball rate of just 45.1%.
Maybe there’s something for Atlanta in the shape of his struggles - he was amazing across five starts for the Clingstones, putting up a 0.96 ERA in 28 innings - before getting absolutely lit up for the Stripers with a 6.79 ERA and 33 walks in 57 innings.
And those struggles might be why the Braves feel comfortable leaving him exposed today: Does another team really want to dedicate an MLB roster spot all season to a pitcher who hasn’t solved Triple-A yet?
It’s possible - he does have the pedigree, and a move to relief might allow the stuff to play up a bit. But unlike some of the others we’ve discussed already, it’s very obvious that the best place for him to be pitching is Triple-A, and the path to being successful in a Major League bullpen right now is a bit harder to see.
My verdict: Bubble. If Atlanta has enough 40-man space, then sure, they could protect him. But I don’t think it’s necessary, and if there’s a roster crunch, this is a calculated risk that I could see the Braves choosing to make.
Other tempting pitchers
Some of these fits are a bit tougher to see, but there’s a reason why someone would consider it, and that’s why we want to talk about it:
Isaac Gallegos
This guy deserves a sentence or two because the numbers were sneaky-good in High-A and Double-A:
56⅔ IP
3.02 ERA
68 K
1.02 WHIP
Again, when you’re a reliever, the path to a successful Rule 5 stash is a bit easier to see. I’d leave him unprotected, but would be a little nervous about it, just like I was with Blake Burkhalter last year.
Julio Robaina
The left-hander isn’t a traditional prospect, having entered professional baseball back in 2018 and spending time in both indy ball and the WBC before Atlanta signed him after Opening Day.
Joining Columbus in mid-May, Robaina threw:
63 IP
3.14 ERA
60 K
1.22 WHIP.
And he has both starting and relief experience, allowing a .671 OPS out of the rotation and a .672 out of the bullpen. He’s another plausible deep cut for a team looking for a cheap lefty/bulk arm with room to grow.
Cory Wall
The numbers would say he’d be a target: a career 2.91 ERA & 154 K in 145⅓ innings, but he barely pitched in 2026 and was most recently on the 60-day IL in the minors.
Rule 5 guys can go on the IL, although there’s a catch: He’d still eventually need to spend 90 days on the active roster before those restrictions disappear, even if it wasn’t until the next season.
The rest
There are some useful traits scattered around Atlanta’s pitching pool in the minors, but there’s not much combination of performance, health, age, and level that makes sense for a Rule 5 claim.
The position players are probably safer than they look
There’s a long list of position players that are eligible to be selected:
Cal Conley
Adam Zebrowski
Archer Brookman
David McCabe
Carson Taylor
Will Verdung
Ambioris Tavarez
Luke Waddell
Cade Doughty
Kevin Kilpatrick Jr.
Lizandro Espinoza
The interesting name here is McCabe, who hit .294/.375/.556 with 20 homers across 325 plate appearances in the upper minors.
That being said, the Rule 5 hurdle for a position player is significantly harder to clear than a pitcher. The arm can be stashed in the back of the bullpen and given a few blowout innings a week. The position player, however, is a guy who likely still needs development but would either burn a bench spot all year or be asked to hit MLB pitching before he’s ready.
Would McCabe be annoying to lose? Sure, because he could be an on-base-focused 1B/DH option sooner rather than later. But it wouldn’t be the end of the world, because even if he’s taken, it’s much harder for position players to last the entire season.
Sure, there are exceptions - catcher Liam Hicks stuck with Miami in 2025, eventually getting moved to Tampa Bay at this year’s deadline, while Nasim Nuñez made it with Washington in 2024…but got just 78 plate appearances all year. For the most part, the standard to even get selected is a lot higher for a bat, and so Atlanta can likely leave them all unprotected (unless they’re just really worried about losing McCabe.)
Guys I’m comfortable exposing
There are several guys who are talented and could still amount to something, but they’re not candidates to get selected.
Cade Kuehler’s a great example of this - he had a 6.34 ERA with 78 strikeouts in 109.1 innings in High-A last year. A team’s not carrying that on the big-league roster all season.
Ian Mejia’s in a similar boat: 7.01 ERA in Rome and Columbus, striking out 67 and allowing 40 walks and 20 homers.
Ambioris Tavarez hit .179 in Columbus, while Will Verdung had only five homers in 331 plate appearances for Rome and Columbus while running a near-50% ground-ball rate. Samuel Strickland is a 27-year-old reliever who had a 6.39 ERA in Columbus.
Making the 40-man space
This is where it gets tough - unless you have open spots, every protection means moving on from someone else.
Atlanta currently has 37 on the 40-man, so they can protect the trio of Polo, De Grandpre, and Vargas without losing anyone already in the organization. But any other addition like McCabe requires a corresponding move.
The Braves aren’t deciding today which player they think will make the majors. Instead, they’re trying to evaluate whether other teams think that player can compete in the majors now.
And that’s why I’m choosing to protect the pitcher who speedran the entire system in five months, as well as the Triple-A reliever who had 105 strikeouts, rather than just grabbing anyone ranked on a prospect list.
Polo, De Grandpre, and Vargas would be my three.


