Welcome back to Braves Today’s Friday Mailbag, where we solicit questions from you, the readers. Doing a mailbag even once, let alone on a regularly scheduled basis, is an egocentric exercise, so I’m grateful to everyone who reached out with questions.
As Jason Isbell sings, “I’m lucky to have the work.”
(If you have something to submit for the mailbag, you can email me at contact@bravestoday.com. Paid subscribers get first priority, but I pull questions from email and social media too.)
Let’s talk about it.
Schafer, Pache, Waters, Heyward (after that wrist injury, he tanked), Maitan, Peraza, Kubitza, Shewmake and Touki.
The list of “can’t-miss” prospects the Braves held onto instead of trading when their value was high goes on and on.
Is there a prospect or two you think fans or the team are overconfident in right now who might join this list someday?
Calvin
People thought The Blues Brothers made up the idea of chicken wire in front of the stage, but it was a real feature at dive bars, honky tonks, and other rowdy live-music venues for a while in the 60s, 70s, and 80s.
I feel like I need to grab some chicken wire before I answer this question.
Leaving out the obvious “they got injured”, let’s talk about some of the “higher-variance” prospects in the system and what might prevent them from making the majors (or sticking once they get there) if things don’t go right.
And yes, I’ll start with each of the “big three”, just to make it fair.
(All prospect rankings come from the Braves Prospect Composite, linked below)
#1 Eric Hartman: whiffs, particularly against secondaries. He’s got a very “catch the ball out in front” swing, and he’s shown vulnerability to pitchers that can locate down-and-away, either breaking balls or a righty’s offspeed pitch. The good news is that most breaking balls down there are from lefties, so there’s still potential to mitigate the issue with platoon protection, but if he never hits his ceiling, it’ll be because he’ll end up being a whiff-prone, power-over-hit-tool left fielder without exceptional defense.
#2 Tate Southisene: defensive shakiness and a lack of impact. Know how there are those wide receivers that can make the amazing, one-handed leaping catches, but then drop a pass that hits them square in the hands while uncovered? That’s Tate Southisene on defense; his lapses are sometimes inexplicable, and he’s not as experienced at shortstop as you’d like (which happens when your older brother, who himself was an MLB draft pick, is on the same high school team as you). As far as power, he hits too many grounders and isn’t elevating the ball quite enough just yet. Still plenty of time to figure it out, and he likely will, but worth mentioning in the context of the question.
#3 Cam Caminiti: lack of continued fastball development. The Braves have already made the Chris Sale-esque mechanical changes to goose the secondaries, and he can locate the fastball well, but he’s not always great at holding the velocity throughout his start. It’s like the reservation: He can show you the velocity early, but holding it is the hard part.1 I think he’d still work out as a back-end guy throwing 92-93, where he ended up later in starts, but getting that average to 95-96 while being able to reach back for high-90s would do wonders.
#4 AJ Gracia: a poor transition to wood bats (or a poor recovery from the labrum surgery). Gracia’s an odd one to me - he wasn’t really producing eye-popping exit velos in college with a metal bat, although the fact that he played through the shoulder injury might account for that somewhat. He also ran roughly 90% contact rates in college, but given the power questions and lack of carrying defensive ability, he’s gotta maintain the contact ability as he gets into pro ball.
#6 Owen Murphy: lack of fastball velo development. Look, Murphy’s fastball shape is excellent, averaging a well-above-average 19 inches of IVB (and doing it from a low release point, to boot), but he too often sits about 92 with it and misses his spots too much when he reaches back for more. Joe Ryan’s made the profile work, but he’s also working with 93-94 on average, and his sweeper/splitter combo is better at getting whiffs than Murphy’s slider/curveball/change.
#7 John Gil: lack of range and power. He’s gonna be a great second baseman sooner rather than later, but Gil doesn’t have a ton of range in his defensive game and I don’t think it’s a surprise that he was the one moving off of shortstop when he’s shared time with Southisene or Alex Lodise. He’s a jack of all trades, but a master of none, and having a lower power ceiling so far and power ceiling questions means he might end up in a utility role.
#9 Conor Essenburg: your power tool’s only as good as your hit tool. He can crush a baseball…if he can make contact with it. Essenburg ran a 69% contact rate last season, sitting at only 79% in the strike zone. The stylistic comp of Kyle Schwarber still makes a ton of sense to me here, as he’ll strike out quite a bit but also draw more than his fair share of walks. He’s our resident King of Three True Outcomes.
#11 Alex Lodise: it’s the Dansby Swanson game, both good and bad. Lodise is a no-doubt shortstop and my favorite of the three shortstop prospects to watch on the diamond. In the batter’s box, though, he’s not been able to as reliably tap into his power as he’s worked to figure out professional pitching. Breaking balls are still a challenge at times, and too much attention on them leaves him vulnerable to velo on occasion.
If there’s anyone I didn’t get to that you specifically want to hear about, let me know.
Do we aim to add one more big move, or two to three smaller moves to fill the holes?
@WaldrepSplitter
If you’ve already done this, my apologies, but would you rank these needs in order of importance: shortstop, left field, designated hitter, starting pitching and relief pitching?
@ChoppinBravos
Two questions from social media thrown together here, because I think they’re related.
To take this backward, right now the biggest priority is shortstop, followed by starting pitching, left field, and then relief pitching, 50 feet of crap, and then designated hitter.
I know that starting pitcher feels like the biggest need right now, but that’s because we’re looking for quality, and that’s harder to find (and doubly so when you have a GM who doesn’t want to pay market rates in free agency). At shortstop, your in-house options at the moment are Jim Jarvis or a career utility option like Brett Wisely, Vidal Bruján, or Luke Williams.
Left field is a situation where you have $25 million tied up in two options in Jurickson Profar ($15M) and Mike Yastrzemski ($10M). We don’t know what Profar will be after only 80 games in two seasons (and when not on the juice), while Yastrzemski didn’t hit his usual 2.0-2.4 WAR last year due to a slow start. Profar’s a complete unknown on whether he’ll perform, whether he’ll make the team, or whether a third positive test would effectively end his career, but if you squint at Yaz through Braves-colored glasses, you could see how he was slightly above average against right-handed pitching from the end of April through the end of the season.
An upgrade would be nice out there, but there are financial obstacles to overcome first.
The rotation, however, has a lot of names but no certainty behind Chris Sale. The difference between the rotation and left field, though, is that we’ve learned the hard way that depth will always work itself out. If you have too many pitchers for your rotation, just wait two weeks; someone will almost certainly go down with forearm inflammation, a sore shoulder, or a UCL issue.
Relief pitching ranks lower than starting pitching both because we’ve already addressed the spot in free agency (by adding Evan Phillips) and because any rotation add bumps someone back to the pen, giving them reinforcements as well.
And designated hitter is last because when everything’s working, you can cover that spot through rotating regulars in it (and when it’s not, having a full-time DH hampers you from load management on your guys).
Honestly, I think we might get one more major move (like a starter, whether that’s in the Freddy Peralta thermosphere, the Tyler Mahle mesosphere, or the “random minor league deal that inexplicably becomes our third-best starter by ERA” troposphere) and then some smaller moves here and there - platoon bat for hitting lefties, buy low bullpen project or utility bat, etc.
Why do you think we did not get Sonny Gray? Did the Braves not get him because it was: 1. Too much money? 2. Too many years? 3. AA doesn’t give opt-outs?
I guess my question is: Is this “proof” that AA’s way doesn’t, can’t or won’t get results in the free-agent market?
John (premium subscriber)
Even if it’s not absolute proof that AA’s insistence on team-friendly contract structure is a problem - we don’t know if Atlanta had an offer in on Gray and he chose to go elsewhere - it’s hard to ignore that most mid- to top-of-the-market free agents often receive player-friendly contract clauses in their deals.
If I had to speculate, I’d assume it’s probably the $30 million player option for the second season that was the hold-up, although as I said on today’s podcast, it’s possible they didn’t want to commit $55 million for a guy that’s losing velocity across the board and saw his fastball production carried almost exclusively by his sinker performance vs. lefties.
(And at this point, mutual options should just be removed from the system - no one’s picked up a single mutual option since 2015, and they pretty much just exist to allow teams to push part of the guarantee to a different accounting year via the buyout - if the 2028 player option gets picked up, Gray will get an additional $5 million when one of the two parties declines the 2029 mutual option.)
More from John:
Given that a lot of Braves Country is also SEC football country, we’re all familiar with the saying, “If you ain’t cheatin’, you ain’t tryin’ (to win)!”
Assuming the lockout happens and, in theory, teams cannot have any contact with players during it, is there any chance teams try to skirt that rule by going through a third party, using Morse code, using burner phones, sending up smoke signals (LOL), or doing something to check up on their pitchers, like the Spencers?
Can Jeremy Hefner just happen to show up at Maven Baseball Lab on a day when one of the Spencers is there to throw? Can Hefner talk to the people who run Maven Baseball Lab to check up on our pitchers who are likely to be working out there during the lockout?
And what is the punishment if caught doing so?
To be clear, I’m not suggesting the Braves cheat. I’m just wondering whether there is a gray area that can be exploited.
I’d expect some teams to attempt to circumvent the rules, although there were no public reports of teams successfully doing it (or attempting to) during the last lockout.
MLB’s official memo on the subject, which was sent to teams on October 1st, specifies that club officials are supposed to avoid players “to the greatest extent possible,” because “the line between permissible and prohibited conversations is not always clear.” Team personnel are instructed to “be cordial” toward players and are specifically allowed to attend a player's wedding during the lockout, but have been instructed to keep conversations surface-level and unrelated to the sport.
So I’d imagine Hefner can’t just show up at Maven while our guys are there, and the Players Association has already indicated it plans to coordinate offseason instruction for their members, similar to what they did in the last lockout.
But talking to Maven staff, depending on the way the business arrangements might be structured, might be okay. As I understand it, the league’s rules encompass any team personnel and outside providers of services working on behalf of the organization. If the players are going to Maven on their own, at their own expense, then that’s a private business relationship between Maven and the player.
That being said, relaying any sort of instruction to the player during the lockout is specifically prohibited. So Hefner might find out how they’re doing with their offseason workouts, but I don’t think he can relay any changes or plans.
As far as medical updates are concerned, the organizations are prohibited from talking to the player, as is the team-contracted doctor who oversaw the player’s surgery and is overseeing their rehabilitation, as I understand. The only notable exception here was Fernando Tatis Jr. during the last lockout; he suffered a minor motorcycle crash that December, and while team doctors weren’t allowed to examine him directly, they were permitted to talk to his private doctors to get updates on his health following the accident. (Tatis ultimately ended up needing surgery for a broken wrist soon after the CBA was signed and didn’t play at all that year, owing to both the injury and a PED suspension).
And no PED testing was conducted during the last lockout. Somewhere, Jurickson Profar’s ears just perked up.
It’s important to point out that we don’t know what kind of punishment would be administered if MLB found out a team was circumventing these rules, but we both know the league office would make an example out of Atlanta, because of course they would.
What did you think of Weiss’s decision-making in his first year, and where can he improve?
@Marcuabonum
For the most part, I think he did a good job. He was particularly adept early at leveraging a strong bullpen to push for wins, backing off later as guys were slumping or otherwise unavailable. And most of the bullpen decisions that we complained about ended up being revealed as more of a roster construction problem after the postgame press conference.
I do think that Weiss needs to be a bit more willing to push guys to rest or half-days, utilizing the DH spot more. Outside of early-season DH option Dominic Smith and can’t-take-his-bat-out-of-the-lineup Drake Baldwin, only Ronald Acuña Jr. (14 games) made more than four starts at DH last year.
Matt Olson, specifically, told 680 The Fan on Thursday that his league-leading 944-game streak, not only the longest active streak but the eighth-longest in MLB history, isn’t something that he’d fight to keep if the team asked him to take a day off. “Sitting out and watching a game is boring. I’d rather be out on the field. But it’s also not one of those things that, if we go into the season and Walt says, ‘I really want to get position players five to 10 off days this year’ […] it’s not something that I’d fight with him over. It’s just not a massive goal of mine.”
And if he’s willing to take a few days off, everyone else should be, too. Obviously, injuries play a large factor here, but if the circumstances allow, I’d like to see him be more aggressive with giving guys a “half-day.”
You sneak a lot of sci-fi references into the newsletter. Do your kids share that interest, and is there a movie series you’ve been wanting to watch together?
Carol
For the most part, they do not, but my seven-year-old son and I are about to start a winter project of watching all 39 official feature-length Godzilla movies during the lockout. The Japanese Toho productions span four different eras, and there are also five American films. Hopefully, we’ll have time (and streaming access) for all of them this winter.
Thanks to everyone who sent a question, and to John and our other paid subscribers for supporting Braves Today.
Enjoy your weekend, everyone.


