18 Comments
User's avatar
Tom Lamoureux's avatar

Outstanding season by the team. The season was made even more enjoyable by Lindsay’s really exceptional commentary and analysis. So glad I found BT and the subscription is best money I spend all year.

Poor NLDS when it did feel like the Dodgers were beatable. Offense never showed up. Muncie out homered the Braves. In game 5, Braves pitchers walked 3 Dodgers, 2 of them scored. Braves had 5 walks and not one of them scored.

On to what hopefully will be a productive off-season and one that ends on-time. My thoughts on Braves needs. Front office has to adapt to the changes occurring in baseball. The biggest change is the velocity of change. Baseball used to evolve over decades. With the advent of advanced analytics, better scouting and other factors, the pace of change in baseball has accelerated. AA built this team when the prevailing strategy was find guys in their early 20’s with talent and lock them up through their most productive years (ages 26/27 - 31/32). This strategy isn’t holding true. Many guys are declining in late 20’s. Riley is not an isolated example. Braves need to deal with this and it could be tough. The second strategy that has changed in the last couple of years - offense is directly correlated to HRs (hit the ball in the air and ignore SOs). Not true anymore. Braves are going to have to find ways to diversify their offense. And lastly, the invest heavily in top end starting pitching philosophy doesn’t work. RIP to the importance of the 5 man rotation. Pitching depth and versatilty is much more important. Fortunately, Braves are in pretty good shape for this and Weiss has shown he understands how to use pitchers outside of the “baseball formula”. The last thing the Braves need is to chase top end, high-priced SP FAs despite the clamor i expect the fans will make.

Michael Harrelson's avatar

Refer to Tampa Bay. Who is their GM?

Tom Lamoureux's avatar

Tampa Bay and Milwaukee are examples of teams that recognize trends early, adapt quickly and take advantage of them. Probably add Cleveland to that list as well. Mariners are a great example of club that followed all 3 of the conventional truths I pointed out and can’t play .500 baseball. The pace of change has increased in the MLB and recognizing the changes and adapting quickly is more important than ever. I think Braves front office is up to the challenge.

Baseball Doc's avatar

Are you trying to convince yourself that the importance of a 5 man starting rotation has declined simply because you know AA is too scared of making a deal for a legit starting pitcher?

Tom Lamoureux's avatar

I’m looking at the data. SP pitchers continue to cover fewer innings. The decline has been occurring for many seasons and continued in 2026. SPs now cover slightly more than half the innings pitched. At the beginning of this century, they covered 65-70%. Three pitchers in the MLB threw 200 innings in 2026. A decade ago, it wasn’t unusual for an individual team to have 3 pitchers with 200 innings. If you define an effective SP as throwing 150 innings with a sub 4.00 ERA, the average team had about 2 in 2025 (haven’t done the analysis for 2026 yet). The world champ, Dodgers, had one. There are many reasons for this, including the increase in spin and velocity and the rise in injuries this is likely causing. At the same time, teams continue to pay SPs like like it was 1995. While it’s close, excellence in runs per game has a higher impact on winning than team ERA. Paying top dollar for a position that isn’t as important as it used to be isn’t an effective way to build a winning team. Look at the 2 best teams in baseball this season. They both trade their best pitchers before they become FAs or get very large contracts in arbitration. I could go on and on. Pitching depth and flexibility is much more important than the traditional 5 man rotation. The 2026 Braves proved this and the front office built a deep staff that delivered in the regular season and the playoffs despite the inevitable extensive injuries.

Tom Lamoureux's avatar

I don’t believe the Braves biggest issue is starting pitching and in baseball SP is an over-valued position. (Not saying it’s not important, it’s over valued). Seems like you don’t agree with either point? Great discussion… look forward to keeping it going during the off-season.

Baseball Doc's avatar

I don't. If the Braves go into the offseason and only resign Tyler Mahle to be the #2 starter, that's not enough. They cannot rely on Spencer Schwellenbach coming back in the SP2 form he was at before his injury. I don't think Spencer Strider can be relied on to be a SP period right now. Could both come back healthy and rebound their performance? Yes, but I'm not going to rely on that just so I can approach free agency and/or trades cheaply. Get me Jacob DeGrom. Get me Sonny Gray. Do that, and the starting pitching issues are over.

Tom Lamoureux's avatar

Keith, when I reread my response, the tone was a little harsher than I would’ve liked. But I stand behind the point. You make good points, but would counter with 3 things. First, the series loss to the Dodgers is almost completely on the offense. If we were to assign responsibility, I’d put 90+% on lack of runs. Would you agree? Second, Fuentes was clearly not himself. We don’t know why, but overuse is likely. Walt had other options he could have turned to, including not pulling the SP. And 100% agree you need a deep pitching staff, thats the point. Should SPs throw more innings? Doesn’t really matter what they “should” do. The data shows what SPs actually do. And lastly, a couple specific examples which don’t prove anything, but might be thought-provoking. In game 2 of rhe NLDS, the Dodgers started a 2x Cy Young SP and Braves started a guy… well he wasn’t a 2x Cy Young winner (love Kerr mode). It was a Braves “bullpen game”. The Dodgers used more pitchers than the Braves. DeGrom? - CY Youngs, awesome pitcher, had a good season. On Sept 25 with his team’s playoff hopes on the line he started against the Twins. The Twins were playing a “meaningless” game and weren’t an offensive juggernaut this season (10th in RpG). How did Jake do? 4 innings, 8 hits, 8 ERs. His team lost and missed the playoffs. The Rangers paid him $38 million for 162 innings and a 4.20 ERA.

Baseball Doc's avatar

Realize that part of the offensive woes vs the Dodgers has a lot to do with the quality of the Dodgers starting pitching. We faced Tarik Skubal with a bullpen game. Skubal, Snell, Yamamoto, and Glasnow is FAR BETTER than Sale/Mahle and pray for hail.

Tom Lamoureux's avatar

One last point. Who do you want? Pitcher A: $38 million / 162 IP / 4.20 ERA. Pitcher B: $800k / 151 IP / 3.44 ERA. It’s crazy… but pitcher A is DeGrom. Pitcher B is Grant Holmes.

Baseball Doc's avatar

So, do you think the fact that they had to use Didier Fuentes for multiple innings on Sunday had no effect on his decline in performance last night? That's what happens when you build your rotation around the bullpen and randomness. What should happen this offseason is that AA should be revisiting Texas on Jacob DeGrom AND also looking to see if Boston will deal Sonny Gray. He has to get one of them if not both. That's wishful thinking though, because I know AA isn't going to do it.

Jonah's avatar

Maybe I’m imagining it, but I swear that when the offense was really rolling at the start of the season they were actually doing a better job with situational hitting and taking what pitchers were giving them. Then at some point the organizational philosophy or hitting coach philosophy or whatever it is took over and they went back to trying to hit the longest distance home run in the history of MLB on every pitch. Whatever the driving force behind it is seems to have really messed Baldwin in particular up, his approach when he first came up and until about June of this season seemed great. He worked counts and adjusted to those counts and took swings that seemed to match up a lot better with the pitches he was seeing and now he looks like all of our other hitters.

william nichols's avatar

With all the proposed changes the Owners want to make; I feel like this may the last time i watch or care about Baseball.

Everything about Baseball is worse than the game I grew up on in the 60s and 70s. No more Appalachian League, watered down expansion baseball, only draft college players, International draft ( of 18 year olds)

Too old for this Crap.

Tom Lamoureux's avatar

I loved following the 60’s and early 70’s baseball. I count myself lucky I was able to follow the Braves back then - warm GA summer nights with WSB on the transistor radio under my pillow. I also find today’s game interesting and enjoyable. Very different, but still enjoyable. I hope you won’t give up on the game.

Bruce Wallace's avatar

I'm a real Walt Weiss fan but I point the finger at him for tonight's disappointing loss. First, should Mahle have been allowed to continue in the 7th? We could argue that for a while but to bring in Fuentes after he had pitched 3.2 stressful innings 48 hours earlier was just stupid. Fuentes didn't have his usual velo and no command and two walks later we have the setting for disaster. Earlier in the year Weiss appeared to always be careful to not overuse Fuentes - "a very valuable young arm". Tonight he was clearly overused and Weiss should have known better. (It also underscores AA's mistake in not getting another high leverage reliever at the trade deadline.) But, even if they had gotten out of the 7th still tied, this teams'ability to move runners along is so pathetic it probably wouldn't have mattered.

Michael Harrelson's avatar

If "Stars shine the brightest when the lights are the hottest", we only have two bats that qualify: Harris and Oz.

*Stop paying high dollar for low value talent (e.g., Yaz, Thomas & Kim are over $36MM in waste).Get rid of them IMMEDIATELY.

*Find options to the Injured to Death Group of Acuna, Murphy (bring back the guy you let go in August), Strider and Riley. Get rid of them once a replacement is found (or now. it won't matter. they just take up space)

Find young option to Olson. He is so slow on pickoffs, Graceful as a 3 legged ox, won't hit more than .250, GIDP candidate in the middle of the lineup.

*Mahle & Dubbie should be resigned.

*Bring up kids to fill 3B, SS, LF, RF,1B & #2 catcher. Maybe we won't beat Philly next year cuz we didn't do crap to get Arreaz to Atlanta. But ANYTHING is better than watching Acuna ABS crap, Acuna not hussle, Acuna backs up nothing in the outfield...

Michael Kramer's avatar

Some Great comments and points being made people with knowledge of the game.

The offense has been a post season problem for several years. This team needs to learn how to manufacture runs versus waiting on the long ball constantly. Really showed up against top pitchers. A table setter OF or SS would be a great addition.

While the BP game can work in a limited timeframe like the postseason it is a risky strategy reliant on your relieves being locked in on any given day. You need inning eaters. At the least 3 reliable SP.

This team cannot and should not count on any injured pitcher in 2027. Maybe 1-2 can contribute.

Resign Mahle, Dubon, Iggy, Suter, and Lee, believe we have option on Ozzy-use it

Find a permanent solution to LF preferably a right handed one, trade or free agency

Find a DH who can also play a little first Matty needs a day off now and then

Kick the tires on Neto, one of Seattle's starters,